"You can't overturn a judgment call, and that's in the rulebook. I understand that," Moss said Friday. "My thing is, I don't understand how a play like that can't be reviewed. We don't have the review just to have it. We have it so that we can get plays like that right."
The controversial play occurred in the ninth inning of the A's 4-3, 10-inning loss at Angel Stadium, when Erick Aybar led off by hitting a high chopper down the first-base line off Dan Otero, who caught the ball as he collided with Moss. Aybar then ran into Otero, and home-plate umpire Greg Gibson awarded Aybar first base because he was obstructed by Moss, who was standing on the chalk.
The A's argued that Aybar veered inside the base line and intentionally ran into Otero, and they believed there was a good chance they would not have needed to use an additional two relievers in the inning -- Fernando Abad and Ryan Cook -- if Aybar did not reach first base.
"I don't fault Aybar, because what he did was smart baseball," said Moss. "I obviously don't fault Danny, because we were trying to make a play, and I don't fault Greg, because I know the play happened so fast, and it's easy to go by what you see, and if you're making that call in real time, I can easily see how either call is made."
But, he continued, "If it's reviewable, I know for a fact it's turned around."
"If you have instant replay," said Melvin, "and you have a play like that and you take a look at it on video … when I first saw it, I didn't think it was as extreme as when I saw it on video."
Moss maintained Aybar was "100 percent" out of the base line when he collided with Otero, something that would've easily been confirmed on replay.
"If that exact play happens in the Wild Card Game, or if it happens in Game 7 or Game 5 or Game 2, any important game, you're telling me we're not allowed to go back and look at it to get it right?" Moss said. "I think this call is overshadowing the fact it was a great baseball game. I think it was a big deal and a big call only because it shows something that we need to improve. If we're going to have the replay system, those are the exact calls the umpires need help with, because it's a judgment call and it's happening so fast. He might miss it, and it's OK."